If you follow new cars, you’ll know that the VZ Commodore is a transitional
model. It uses a body design that was fundamentally introduced with the 1997 VT
Commodore, suspension which has been tweaked but dates back even further – and a
brand new, high tech, quad cam, 3.6-litre engine.
So, an on-paper summary would suggest that the body and suspension design
might now be getting a bit tired, but that the cutting-edge engine rescues the
package. That might be what you’d think – but you’d be wrong, wrong, wrong!
In fact, the new engine is the weak link in the car’s mechanical make-up.
On test was the $40,990 Acclaim wagon, complete with the old four-speed auto
and 175kW version of the new Alloytec engine. Australians buy family wagons like
this to, er, carry families – and often do so over long distances. So, we
thought, what better task than to drive the car from the Gold Coast to Sydney
and return, complete with a young baby in the back and the amount of gear that
only a first-time mother can think to bring along?
The road followed the inland route down the New England Highway - about as
typical an Australian secondary country road as it’s possible to find. We then
joined the freeway at Newcastle, spent two days with the car parked at the hotel
in Sydney, and then returned the same way. The total distance was about 2500
kilometres, completed in four days.
Interestingly, there was a second car accompanying the Holden on the return
trip – a 1969 Austin 1800, which had just been purchased. This limited the
return speed to 90-100 km/h. With the trip down completed at the 100/110 km/h
open road speed limits, it can be seen that the Commodore was most times just
Fuel economy? Well, it should have been exceptional – what with all that new
alloy gee-whiz wizardry under the bonnet and the slow open road speeds.
But it wasn’t.
We averaged 9.2 litres/100 km and can confidently say that we can’t imagine
anyone with a VZ Commodore wagon getting better in any real world use. That
consumption is at least 10-15 per cent worse than we expected in these
conditions, and in fact poorer economy than we have heard the old 3.8 litre
pushrod engine getting in similar trips.
And the performance? If it was scintillating, that economy would be forgiven
- but it simply isn’t.
The 0-100 km/h time we gained (car unladen, one person, low fuel) was about
9.3 seconds 0-100 – certainly nothing to write home about. But more important
than the bare number is that on the road, the car never feels particularly
punchy. The new engine has a very flat torque curve (ie there’s higher than
usual power available at all revs), but the absolute torque output isn’t very
great. In other words, this is a car that needs to automatically change back a
gear when confronting only modest hills. Dial in the (very good) cruise control,
get on the open road and the engine feels quite gutless. When it sees a hill, it
firstly drops out of overdrive torque converter lock-up, then is often forced
to change back to third gear.
Of course, lots of modern V6 engines behave in a very similar manner, needing
revs on board to pull the tall gearing up hills. But without any exceptions,
those engines are far sweeter than the Holden’s. For this is an engine that
noisy and harsh, at high revs feeling strained and unhappy. It’s simply
light-years less refined and sweet than any Toyota six cylinder engine of the
last decade, noticeably inferior to the Ford six, and not even as good as the
now quite old Magna V6.
Compared with the superb Honda Accord V6 (incidentally, a car in the same
price range), the Alloytec feels like it’s from a different, long ago era.
In fact, it’s impossible to describe any aspect of the engine (apart from its
electronic throttle control, which we’ll come to) as a highlight. Idle quality?
– poor, and at times (when heat soaked?) astonishingly poor. Economy? –
certainly not outstanding. Performance – nothing to write home about. NVH? –
And the auto trans shows its age, with only four ratios and lacking a
‘tiptronic’ style function to allow the driver to easily operate the ‘box in a
But the rest of the car? Paradoxically, it’s damn’ good!
Holden engineers have been refining their MacPherson strut/semi-trailing
rear-arms-plus-a-link suspension for years. In this car they’ve sharpened the
steering a little and what feels like further finessed the dampers. And the
result is exceptional. The car rides absolutely superbly and its handling is
really very, very good.
The steering initially feels almost too quick for a family wagon but after a
few kilometres, familiarity breeds delighted acceptance. The bane of old-school
Commodores – the traction control system that was awful in both V8 and V6 forms
– has been banished, being replaced by a system that through its activation of
the electronic throttle, is subtle and very effective. Throw the big car into a
succession of tight and twisties and it’s enormously impressive: there’s some
warning understeer but otherwise the car is neutral and well-balanced.
Furthermore, even though the 205/65 tyres are relatively tall and skinny, the
absolute grip levels are quite high. (But unfortunately electronic stability
control is fitted only to the Acclaim sedan, not the wagon.)
On the road – whether that’s a freeway, dirt, potholed bitumen or coarse chip
tar – the VZ feels refined, composed and competent. About the only glitch is
that in gusty crosswinds it can be blown around a little.
The interior also works very well. The room is enormous, the seats huge and
comfortable and the dashboard controls chunky but effective. As you’d expect in
a car like this, the air-con is effective (even with the added cabin volume of
the wagon) and ventilation is very good. In fact, while we’re sure some of you
will laugh in disbelief, the Commodore’s on-road feel, headlights, ventilation
and comfort make some double-the-dollars Euros look completely unsuited to this
The Acclaim is also well equipped with four airbags, ABS, cruise control and
an excellent trip computer that also allows various functions - such as road
speed-dependent sound system volume control – to be set to suit personal
preference. You can even bring up a digital speedo.
If you don’t care much about performance, fuel economy or engine refinement,
we’re sure the Acclaim wagon will impress – its packaging, ride and handling are
just so good. But right now Holden has the job with this new engine ahead of
them. We’re sure that over time there will be dramatic improvements wrought to
it (there’ll have to be!) but that leaves the VZ in an odd position: with the
exception of the trans, what is old is good and what is new is – in relative
terms – bad. Never just judge specs on paper...
The Holden Acclaim wagon was made available for this test by Holden.