Magazines:  Real Estate Shopping: Adult Costumes  |  Kids Costumes  |  Cars  |  Guitars |  Electronics
This Issue Archived Articles Blog About Us Contact Us
SEARCH


Don't Bother Changing the Factory Filter

Most times it's just wasting money

by Julian Edgar

Click on pics to view larger images

At a glance...

  • Putting an aftermarket drop-in filter in the factory airbox seldom improves flow.
Email a friend     Print article
This article was first published in 2004.

We’ve been saying it for years but it’s a message that doesn’t seem to have widely got through. Nine times out of ten, dropping an aftermarket filter into the standard factory airbox is not going to get you any more power.

None.

Zilch.

Bugger-all.

Factory airfilters have excellent flow and they’ve also got filtration that matches the car manufacturer’s stringent criteria. Put a different filter in the box and not only will there be almost certainly no improvement in flow, there’ll also be an unknown decrease in filtering efficiency. That’s a pretty dumb combination to pay money for.

The way that you can easily assess the flow capability of the filter is to measure the pressure drop across it. No flowbench is required – just your normal car breathing in lots of air. (Which flows more than all but the hugest of flowbenches, anyway.) A sensitive pressure gauge with two ports that’s plumbed to either side of the filter will measure the difference in pressure at times of high flow. That difference in pressure shows how much flow restriction there is.

More pressure drop = worse flow.

Click for larger image

Suitable pressure gauges for this application include the Dwyer Magnehelic gauges (they’re big but beautifully built and very accurate) or the smaller Dwyer Minihelic gauges (not so well built but still fine in this application).

The gauges can also be used to show the restriction of the whole intake system, just by plumbing the low pressure port to the intake before the throttle body (or turbo) and leaving the other port open to air.

In the case of the guinea pig car being used in this story – a 1988 Toyota Crown Supercharger - a 0-20 inches of water Minihelic gauge is mounted permanently on the dash. The car was bought and the gauge installed before any other changes were made to the standard car. In normal cruise, the gauge shows a pressure drop through the whole intake of 5 inches of water – very little.

At full-load, full revs, that rises to 20 inches of water, which is getting too high for max power development. (Any pressure drop will harm power, but usually getting the maximum intake pressure drop down to below 5 inches of water isn’t worth it for the amount of effort involved.)

Click for larger image

Given that the car was bought secondhand, it was likely that the factory airfilter was dirty. And an inspection revealed that oh, boy was it ever filthy. In fact, the amount of dirt that came out when it was tapped on a surface was mind-boggling.

Click for larger image

And just compare the dirty old filter and the clean new one...

So whack in the new filter and the total pressure drop through the intake will drop by a helluva lot, right? Like, maybe it will now be only 10 inches of water?

In went the new filter and onto the road went the car. And at maximum power the intake restriction remained exactly the same – 20 inches of water.... The brand spankers new clean filter made no difference to intake flow over the old, filthy filter. Y’see, that old filthy filter still flowed very well...

But aaah, you’re saying. What about without the factory filter in the box at all? Well, we did that test as well and if we were paid for imagining things, we might have seen a fractionally lower peak pressure drop – say, 19.5 inches of water...

To put it as simply as possible, there’s no problem with the flow of the factory filter – even when it’s dirty.

And we’ve seen the same story on everything from an Audi S4 to a Subaru Liberty RS to a Nissan Maxima V6 Turbo to a Commodore VL Turbo to a Honda Insight to a Toyota Prius to a....

In nearly all cases, in a standard or only slightly modified car, it’s not the factory filter element which is causing the restriction. Instead, it’s likely to be the snorkel going into the airbox, or even the shape of the airbox itself.  

Don’t start off by changing the filter; start off by altering the intake flow into the box.

Did you enjoy this article?

Please consider supporting AutoSpeed with a small contribution. More Info...


Share this Article: 

More of our most popular articles.
How tyres really work on the road

Technical Features - 9 August, 2007

Tyres, Grip and All That

Ten great home workshop ideas

DIY Tech Features - 16 May, 2008

Useful Ideas

Giving factory seats more support and comfort

DIY Tech Features - 17 March, 2009

Reshaping Factory Seats

The advantages of small boosted engines running direct injected ethanol

Special Features - 16 June, 2009

Going Direct Injected Turbo Ethanol!

The electric motor and control system for a DIY electric bike

DIY Tech Features - 11 February, 2005

Building an Electric Bike Part 2

A brand new approach to road car intercooling

Technical Features - 8 July, 2003

The Fusion Intercooler

The mechanics of diesel engine fuel systems

Technical Features - 20 January, 2007

Common Rail Diesel Engine Management, Part 1

Step by step of keeping drill bits sharp

DIY Tech Features - 20 August, 2008

Sharpening Drill Bits

Cars that go but don't drink

Special Features - 16 June, 2008

Performance with Economy

A home-built jet-powered kid's scooter...

Feature Cars - 23 January, 2007

John's Jet Madness!

Copyright © 1996-2014 Web Publications Pty Limited. All Rights ReservedRSS|Privacy policy|Advertise
Consulting Services: Magento Experts|Technologies : Magento Extensions|ReadytoShip